Monday 22 September 2008, 9:41 AM
Has Symbian thought open source through?
We also got shown some of the fruits of Symbian's work with Scalado on the graphics front. The engineer demonstrated very quick loading of and zooming into a 21-megapixel picture, which was very impressive but raised two unanswered questions. Firstly, given the size of a mobile phone's camera lens and sensor, why on earth would anyone want to stick 21MP in there?
And, more importantly, what precisely is to happen with this valuable work once Symbian goes open source? Given that doing so will involve stripping out all the third-party, proprietary stuff that can't go open source, why is Symbian still bothering with such partnerships? I've spoken since with a mobile developer who reckons the only way they could make, for instance, the Scalado thing work would be to throw enough money at Scalado to get them to allow their tech to be opened up.
Either way, it seems clear that there's a bit of a disconnect within Symbian's organisation. Management may have decided it would be a good idea to go open source, but the way the company works lower down will make this a more-than-tricky task. The engineer demonstrating the work with Scalado didn't have the foggiest as to how current work and the open source policy will merge. Neither do I.
Comments on this post
Good thoughts. I was sorry to miss that event - sounds like they had interesting stuff to talk about.
Hi David,
As always, you ask good questions.
I've tried to answer your main question here:
http://www.dw2-0.com/2008/09/open-source-coexistence-with-marvellous.html
(I may get back to your rather different questions about "why quad core?" and "why 21 mega pixels?" on another occasion...)
// David Wood, Symbian
(Hmm, this is the second time I've typed all this in. The first set seems to have disappeared down a bit bucket.)
Thanks for that, David - that was a very informative post and one that I shall have to mull over for a bit. I'd be interested to know roughly how many such partnerships Symbian currently has and, at the end of this open-sourcing road in a year or two, how many adopted the different business models you detail in your post.
Either way, this is certainly a brave new world of negotiation you're entering into, and I wish you and your team the best of luck. Very much looking forward to seeing the results.


