Advertisement
Promo

Become a member of the ZDNet UK community

Rupert Goodwins

View blog's RSS Feed

Mixed Signals

Any sufficiently advanced information is indistinguishable from noise

Wednesday 21 January 2009, 7:02 PM

Chinese whispers across London airwaves

Posted by Rupert Goodwins

It is a useful convention in international affairs that anywhere in the world, a country's embassy is its sovereign territory. This covers a multitude of sins and helpful tax breaks, but gets particularly interesting when you consider wireless regulation. Radio waves don't stop at embassy walls – so if the ambassador gets it into their head that they want to start a pirate radio station, there's nothing much to stop 'em.

Normally, of course, nobody wants to make a fuss. It is accepted that embassies will sit there snooping on whatever they can hear from the city around them while transmitting what they like back to base (and, sometimes, to local spies – but that's normally thought of as bad form and is in any case a bit bleedin' obvious).

But in these modern days, the possibilities are greater. What to make of a rumour alluded to by mobile phone industry watcher Cat Keynes, who at the bottom of a posting about Chinese 3G standards, says:

It will be interesting to see what the Chinese do about security. Take a GSM phone to China today and you’ll get a warning that there is no encryption. WCDMA has much better encryption and you can be sure the Chinese authorities will want to be able to intercept calls. Perhaps they will have to rely on listening through the network operator. Of course that’s not an option they have in the UK which might account for some interesting network planning issues around the Chinese Embassy in London. They wouldn’t perhaps be running a phantom cell so that they can listen to calls and read the text messages of the Free Tibet protesters outside would they?

This ties in nicely with a rumour I'd heard, that one of the Free Tibet protesters who stand outside the Chinese Embassy in London phoned a friend who was on their way down to join in the fun. Said friend made a joking reference to coming along equipped to do naughtiness – and moments later, the police turned up and proceeded to nab the original caller. They made it plain that it was because of the call.

And, of course, it's not illegal for the Chinese to run such a cell within their embassy. It's possible, and one would expect it to be probable were such an enterprise in effect, for the cell or cells to be configured to pretend to be the mainstream networks. And if so, who can tell whether there is co-operation with the operators for hand-overs (and, perhaps, putting the phantom cells in the base station databases to fool people with applications which can reveal cell IDs and locations – CellFinder on Android is a very good example)?

So, if you're in the habit of wandering around wthin a few hundred yards of embassies, bear in mind that it is perfectly legal, perfectly possible and perfectly likely for your calls to be intercepted and monitored. GSM encryption? Doesn't matter: that only handles the link between the mobile and the base station. If you're at the base station, you can get the decrypted content – sometimes, with enormous consequences.

Best be careful what you say, eh? Mind how you go.

Comments on this post

David Mery

The ACLU obtained obtained documentation on the 'Triggerfish' technology used by the FBI to do mobile base station simulation for surveillance purpose (the Chinese embassy is unlikely to be the only one conducting surveillance ops in London). This blog post contains a link to the PDF:
http://blog.aclu.org/2008/11/14/with-technology-like-this-who-needs-the-law/

br -d.

Posted by David Mery on Jan 22, 2009 1:38 PM

roger andre

Outrageous! I'm speechless!

Ok I'm not speechless, I wonder how long it'll be before such surveillance tech finds its way into the public domain and maybe applications are written to tell you when that phone call you are making is no longer private.

Posted by roger andre on Jan 22, 2009 2:53 PM

Rupert Goodwins

M. Mery - interesting stuff as always(and well worth downloading, that PDF). I'm tempted to wander past the PRC's gaff with my G1 running CellFinder and see what happens; if it's something anomalous, it may be fun to do the same elsewhere in the diplomatic quarter.

Although how long one can do this before being fingered by our mutual friends, I don't know. Should be an interesting conversation, though.

Posted by Rupert Goodwins on Jan 22, 2009 5:34 PM

Rupert Goodwins
  • Rupert Goodwins
  • Location, location, location
  • Member since: October 2006
ZDNet Staff

My Blog Archive


Contacts' Latest Discussions

Number of Tracked Discussions: 3,224

ator1940 ator1940

Personal Financial Management Software...

Wednesday 9 December 2009, 10:00 AM

3 comments
manek manek

Context is Everything

Wednesday 9 December 2009, 9:42 AM

1 comment
manek manek

Why don't people delete old emails?

Wednesday 9 December 2009, 9:30 AM

5 comments

Contacts' Latest Blogs

Number of Contacts Blogs: 18


Skip Sub Navigation Links to CNET Brand Links

Help

Become part of the ZDNet community.

Newsletters